Video: Embedding Food & Product Safety Culture: From the Floor to the Boardroom | Duration: 4320s | Summary: Embedding Food & Product Safety Culture: From the Floor to the Boardroom | Chapters: Welcome and Introduction (0.96s), NSF's Global Impact (330.29s), Introducing Culture Excellence (865.36s), Influencing Food Safety Culture (3045.46s), Effective Training Methods (3310.6s), Resolving QA Conflicts (3627.735s), Measuring Cultural Change (3841.16s), Concluding Questions Answered (4024.73s), Survey Frequency Considerations (4149.445s)
Transcript for "Embedding Food & Product Safety Culture: From the Floor to the Boardroom": Okay. Thank you. Thank you, everyone. Welcome to the webinar on embedding food and product safety culture from the floor to the boardroom. We are on top of the hour, and we'll start now. We are excited to have you here and to learn more about how a strong safety culture ensures safe products, protects consumers, and strengthens brand trust. My name is Prateek, and I will be your moderator for today. First, there are some housekeeping announcements that I have to make to ensure optimal broadcasting efficiency. Only the speakers, they will have access to the microphone during the webinar. We encourage you to use the chat feature located on the right side of your screen to share your thought or ask any questions. We will address the questions during the dedicated q and a session at the last of the event. If you experience any technical difficulties, please try refreshing your browser or checking your Internet connection. If the problem persists, please let us know in the chat, and we'll try to assist you in the best way we can. So without much ado, let me welcome our esteemed or okay. I'll I'll first run you through the agenda. As I said, we do have an exhaustive agenda to cover today. I'll do the basic introduction of the speakers followed by Nidhi, who is my colleague at NSF, taking over responsibility of introducing NSF to people who do not know. Then it will get passed on to Virender, who is representing NSF LGC group, to speak a little bit about BRCGS and LGC. And then the highlight of the webinar that we have been waiting for, doctor Johan Taylor would speak about the cultural excellence, and then it would be followed by a dedicated q and a session at the last of the webinar. So without much ado, let me just dive into the speaker introduction. So we've got a panel full of experienced people across food industry. We have doctor Joanne Taylor, who is a seasoned professional with twenty five plus years of experience working in various capacities across industry, academia, and the government sector. She holds a PhD in risk management and behavior change apart from holding a bachelor's degree in psychology. We welcome you, Joanne, to this webinar. We also have Virender, who is the BRCGS representative for India and the APAC region with over seventeen years of experience. He spent over thirteen years in the tech industry focusing on the certification market, growth, and start strategic account development. Virender has specialized working internationally with BRCGS in the past seven years. He has actively worked as part of the BRCGS global commercial team, generating new business and actively contributed to BRCGS revenue growth. And the the other lady on the panel, we have Nidhi, who is our technical manager at NSF. She's a seasoned expert in the food safety and quality domain, currently serving as the business lead for food and nutrition at NSF. She has been associated with companies like Britannia, National Commodities Management Service Limited, and Sealed Air in the past with a robust background in business strategy, CRM, quality management, and food safety. She has significantly contributed to the food and beverage and allied industry. She holds an MBA from Anand Agriculture University and an engineering degree from AD Battelle Institute of Technology. Nidhi's expertise and insight make her a valuable addition to our today's panel. So welcome, Nidhi. Welcome, Virendar, and let's get started. So before we do that, I have a poll question which should help us warm up to the webinar topic, so which I'm throwing open to all of you now. It should come on your screens. So just try and answering this question. So we should be able to understand how exactly do you feel about the organization culture in your organize the food safety culture in your organization. I can see some words have already started coming in. So yeah. I'll give it another fifteen seconds. Okay. Okay. So, yes. So I think we have had about 40 odd submissions. And most of them, they tend to be suggesting that there is some amount of, you know, improvement that is required in the food safety culture across organizations. So, yes, I think this webinar should certainly help us understand how to understand first what are the deficiencies that exist in the system, how to identify those, and how to try and do the corrective measures. So with that, I'll pass it on to Nidhi to give us an overview about NSF. Over to you, Nidhi. Thank you, Prateek. A very good afternoon to all these participants joining us from across the globe for our interesting knowledge sharing session today. I am Nidhi Kanagat, leading the food and nutrition business for the NSF across India and the Middle East region. And it's my pleasure to welcome you all for today's webinar. As someone deeply engaged in the food businesses of every scale across this region, I take pride in representing NSF, a brand that has become synonymous with trust, scientific excellence, and global public health protection. For those of you who may be interacting with NSF for the first time, let me share about NSF's foundation and legacy. Since 1944, we have been dedicated to the improvement of human and planet health. This mission is upheld daily by thousands of NSF experts worldwide, including our microbiologists, auditors, stereotoxicologists, chemists, trainers, advisers, environmental scientists, and public health professionals. And together, they work to create safe assistance, protect consumers, and build a healthier world. We are spanned across 110 countries. We are spanned across 110 countries with offices in the North America, Latin America, Middle East, Africa, Oceania, Asia Pacific, India, and The Middle East. Some of the brands that NSF has been working for for over three, four decades are all on in front of your system. And these are brands that take pride in being associated with NSF as much as we do with them. Together, we have grown as a brand and instilling food safety across our processes. NSF's capabilities is anchored in deep scientific and technical expertise across four interconnected domains, The food and nutrition, water, life sciences, and something that has a holistic value add layer across all industries is the assurance services. The food and nutrition where we are the go to partner for the farm manufacturer, processor, packager of the food, beverages, nutrition, and the wellness product industries. Our work ensures that the highest levels of product safety, quality, integrity, and sustainability across the supply chain is followed through. Whether it's your primary production, it's processing, supply chain operations, retail, or front end outlets, NSF supports all sorts of businesses with the testing, auditing, certification, training, risk management, and advisory solutions. From the source to the tap, NSF sets global benchmark for the safety, performance, and quality of water products and systems. With comprehensive testing, certification, and advisory services, we help manufacturers utilize utilities and regulators ensure safe drinking water is ensured. Effective treatment solutions are given that enable trusted water related technologies to reach the world. In the life sciences sector, we provide end to end regulatory, clinical, and quality support across the entire product life cycle. This includes the pharmaceuticals, the biotechnology, medical devices, in vitro diagnostics. And our work enables companies to navigate complex regulations and bring safe, effective, life enhancing products to the patients. NSF is a mark of trust. Brands take pride in this. We have various programs that help companies with this, whether it be raised without antibiotics, the non GMO, USDA organic, safer by choice, NSF Certified Passport, NSF PFAS, and those in the seafood industry. NSF is committed to elevating industry standards while anticipating challenges of the future. For the past eighty two years, our expertise has enabled businesses to adapt, innovate, and deliver products and services that consumers can trust. We have over 3,000 people in our team that are asset. We have helped over 6,000,000 products being certified. We, as an organization, have published one sixty plus standards and protocols. NSF has over 3,000,000 audits that we have completed. We work around the clock with 40,000 clients, and it's been eighty two years since inception. It's not just the scale, but trust, impact, and legacy of scientific credibility. On your farms, in your factories, or on the road in your stores, or your restaurants, NSF has innovated since the dawn of modern food service operations to improve safety and quality. Whatever support you need at any step of your supply chain, NSF is your one stop solution. If you go to the document section of this webinar, you will see a lot of literature and information that we have shared with you about NSF, what we do, and how we contribute, and how you benefit. A good part of our contribution to the food sector comes through our partnership with the RCGS, a global leader in the food safety and brand protection standards. NSF is an approved BRCGS certification body for food safety, packaging material, storage and distribution, agents and brokers, gluten free certification. Our teams bring global expertise and regional understanding to support companies in achieving and maintaining the certification while strengthening their safety culture and operational resilience. And a proud moment on the onset of 2026, NSF has been globally awarded by the VRCGS as the best CV for our contribution across the schemes. Across this region, NSF has supported thousands of businesses through GFSR recognized certifications, second party supplier audits, regulatory study label review compliance advisory, BRCH CGS approved trainings, capability building and leadership programs, product certifications, gap assessments, risk assessments, and improvement road maps. Through it all, our goal remains consistent. To help business deliver safe, reliable, and high quality food with confidence. And that's why we are here today. The food safety culture, which has now become a central pillar for global standards, including the BRCGS. It determines whether the food safety is truly lived and practiced across organization. A strong culture ensures leadership commitment, consistent behaviors, clear communication, empowered teams, and doing it the right way every single day. Today's session will help you understand how to build, measure, and sustain their this culture in real operational environments. So on that note, let's begin. Over to you, Virendra. Thank you. Good morning, good afternoon, and good evening to everyone. I understand we have delegates from across the world, so that is really empowering and motivating for us. I am here to quickly introduce PRCGS and to share how we are committed to the culture, food safety and product safety culture before I give it give the stage to Joe who is the cofounder of the culture excellence program. So yeah. I I am Virendra, like I mentioned, and I represent BRCGS in Asia Pacific region. As of BRCGS, we are a standards organization. We ensure a safe supply chain across the world. There are about 10 standards that BRCGS has written so far. We've got 37,000 plus organizations that are we are seeing as certified. The primary standard here is the food itself. We are operating in a 140 plus countries across the world, and there are about 82 partners delivery partners who we are working with. We can also call them certification bodies. We have professional BRCGS professionals who are enrolled with BRCGS from these certified organizations. There are over fifteen fifteen thousand members now, so that's really empowering. And these are some other stats that you can refer to as well. Moving forward, there's a quick snapshot of our journey in last thirty years. We recently completed thirty years of our journey. We were established in 1996 by the British Retail Consortium Consortium to reduce the audit duplications by The UK retailers. So we were then called PRC Global Standards. And in 1998, we published our first standard which was a global standard for food. And in 2000, we were the first ever standard to be recognized by GFSI. So it's the first, and we have been been at the forefront of these standards for over, you know, thirty years now. So over the next few years, we launched multiple standards including packaging materials, consumer products, and storage and distribution standard as well. In 2016, we started working on the culture. We joined hands with the culture excellence team, Joe here. And in 2017, we launched the RCGS food safety culture excellence module. This was targeted at the organizations who are certified to not only BRCGS, but any other team who can, do this, culture assessment so where the organization find out the areas of improvement, and work throughout the years to improve the culture in the organization. So after 2017, we launched a few more standards as well. We, acquired, an organization called Allergen Control Group for free from standards as well. Moving forward, I just wanted to quickly give you an overview of the food safety culture. We all know that a positive food safety culture, it's the fundamental, to the successful functioning of any food hygiene system or any organization. So, and there are global drivers to, ensure that there, there must be a food safety culture in the organization. We have seen that GFSI now has it's part of the requirement to have for all the standards owners to have a requirement in their standard for the food safety culture development plan, which a site that is getting certified must have in the organization. So it's part of the regulations. It's part of the standards as of now these days. And because of the unannounced audits, it becomes imperative to have the food safety culture, strong culture in the organization, and continuous improvement as well because culture is something that cannot be changed overnight. You need to work towards having a strong culture in the organization, and it's a journey that we must take together. And then now we have seen multiple brand owners and retailers globally. They are focused on the culture assessment, and they ask organizations to assess their culture in the organization to ensure that the the food safety culture is there in the organization. So that's why, this culture assessment tool has been, developed by our partner organization, culture excellence team, which you will see in just some time. Over the many years since we launched in 2017, the the food safety culture excellence module, we have seen that multiple organizations globally had a nonconformance in the food safety and culture requirement of the standard, which is was one point one point two. So we've seen that organizations were not able to properly understand or have a strong, you know, culture development plan in the organization. It was one of the highest ever nonconformers globally in multiple countries, and this data is from India itself and which was recently taken. So here we see that why the culture is important in the organization and how this tool will help you get ahead from your peers across the world. So with this, I just wanted to share some details here that, you know, we are available. I'm available with the NSF team as well to have a conversation with you to support you with any questions. We'll answer many of them in this webinar as well. But after that as well, we'll be happy to connect with you. With this, thank you so much. I'll hand it over to Joe now who will take you through the slides of the culture assessment. Joe, over to you. Thank you very much, Verenda, and thanks to the team today for inviting me to be here. It is a great opportunity to have a conversation about all things culture. So what I wanted to cover today after a short are some of the main questions that I top down approach, or should we take a bottom up approach? And finally, what should I do first? So these are four of the big questions that I get asked, and that's what I'm gonna look at today in this short presentation before we can go to some of your questions. So I've been introduced a little bit at the start. My background is very much embedded within psychology and behaviour change. And I'm one of the two co founders of Culture Excellence. And what we do at culture excellence and where the information comes from that I'll talk about is we assess culture. We assess food safety culture, quality culture, and other different types of culture within organizations. I've been working with my team to conduct research and development in the area for more than twenty five years, and we have assessed more than 12,000 workplaces around the world in more than a 120 countries and in more than 75 different languages. So what I talk to you about today is very much a global perspective. And where this journey has come from and where you might have seen culture excellence before, we started doing our research within multiple universities and with the UK government. And it was in 2014 that we partnered with an organisation some of you may have heard of called Camden BRI to assess culture more formally in industry. We partnered with BRCGS a couple of years later in 2016 to not only work with our big culture assessments, but also to launch a smaller culture assessment that is quicker, easier, and cheaper to use for companies. And then in '2 in 2021, we started a third partnership for another different type of the market, which is a free mini product for companies that we would consider small or less developed who just want to do a very small part of a culture assessment. So what we can do is work with large companies on a full culture assessment. And then if they have smaller suppliers, for example, they can recommend to them to do the free mini tool. But we really want to reach across the full industry and get everybody to understand more about their safety and quality culture. We had our ten year anniversary just last year of formally assessing organizational culture in industry and launched an industry forum so that we're working even more closely together with the food industry. So why is culture so important? Why are we all talking about it? Why was it written into the BRCGS scheme? Why is it being written into government policies and industry requirements all around the world? Well, the reason is it's this hidden factor that can drive an organization's performance and protect their brand when it's going well, but cause serious issues when there are problems. But like an iceberg, most of it's invisible. So we face challenges when we try to measure, identify, and even talk about culture when so much of it isn't visible to us on the surface. We consider culture as the attitudes and behaviors of people working in organizations that are taught to them directly through direct communication and messaging, but also indirectly from what they pick up from the people around them and the people that lead them. So it's these indirect, unspoken ways of learning about the company that can be really influential on employees but are harder to judge and look at. And we know that if you have a good culture, it's a really strong competitive advantage for you as a company. And we know that where there are weaknesses in culture, this is a leading indicator of risk. So we know it's something really important to understand and to continually work on and improve as an organization. The best organizations, they understand their culture, and they were continually working to improve it. But how do we get there? And one of the big questions that people ask in terms of how do I change my culture, well, we have to understand culture first. And when we talk about understanding culture, a lot of the time, we will do this through a culture assessment. So my organization does culture assessments, and we gather data. But data is only the first step on the journey. We have to get from data to wisdom. You may have seen the data to wisdom triangle. You may have seen the data to wisdom circle. But, essentially, we want to move from information to action. So we get data when we take an assessment, a survey on culture. And then, typically, a data platform will organize and structure the data for you with charts and graphs and figures so that you can see where your highs and your lows are. And it's in the analysis of this information and understanding the information, the human interaction with that information that we can create knowledge. And then from that knowledge, it's only if we act that we put things into practice that we generate wisdom and then culture change. So the journey is about assessing your culture using a survey tool, for example. It's about organizing and structuring the information that comes out, analyzing that in the context of your company. What does it mean for us, that human involvement with the numbers, and then working out a plan to act. And it's in the action that we get positive culture change. So this is a really important journey that we're always going to be involved in in our organizations. There's no such thing as a perfect culture. It doesn't exist because no organization stays static. It's moving and changing all of the time with the people and the processes and the outside world being involved. So it's not about perfection. It's about being on this continual improvement and understanding journey. So another question I get asked a lot, how can I make changes that will work for everybody? Or why doesn't what I'm doing work as effectively as I thought it would? And this is a great picture to illustrate the point that one size rarely fits all. It's a cute little picture, lots of people wearing the same suit, and it not fitting any of them particularly well because, obviously, people are all very different. They may work in the same organization that faces the same challenges, but each of them will have a unique experience of interacting with those challenges. You might have heard the saying, treat people as you'd like to be treated. And it's a lovely saying. It's a great sentiment. But we like to flip this when we talk about organizational culture and say treat people as they'd like to be treated. Just because something works for you as the manager or the leader doesn't mean it'll work for others. People come from different cultures and backgrounds. People have different needs and motivations. People are of different ages, so have different learning styles and ways of interpreting information, different ways of interacting with the world. So it's really important that we look at each situation, each new initiative, whether it's a new training scheme, a new reward scheme, whatever it is we're doing to try and improve the culture of our organization that we really get to know and understand the people that we're applying it to. The culture survey is one way of doing this, and there'll be other things in your toolkit of getting to know people in your organization. The more you get to know them, the more effective this will be. And then it will come down to one of the many balances of leadership. Leadership is a constant balancing act. We never have just one thing. We have multiple things, and we have to find the right balance. Because while you want your training and reward and all of your initiatives to be effective for each person, you need them to be efficient. You can't come up with something completely different for everyone. So it's finding that balance between what works for most and how can I tweak it so that it works well for others as well? How much flexibility do I need, but how much consistency can I drive? And awareness and knowledge is really key to this. Another really big question that links to this is when you're thinking about culture, embedding culture, or changing culture, should you take a top down approach, which is really about focusing on the leaders and the impact they make on the organization, or should you focus on a bottom up approach where you focus on the workforce and the impact they have on the culture of the organization? And as I said, in leadership, it's never one path. Like most things, this is a balancing act as well because you actually have to do both. You have to think about culture top down, and you have to think about culture bottom up. And you have to have strategies and ideas in place that work on both levels. Let's take top down first. Start from the top. So how do we utilize top down methodologies in terms of culture change? Let's go around the four different categories of culture as we do this. So as you probably know, in culture excellence, we divide culture into four different categories. We talk about the people, the processes, the proactivity, and the purpose. So let's look at these one by one. Let's start with people. How can we utilize top down approaches with people? People in culture is about empowerment. It's about reward and recognition. It's about making sure people are trained and communicated with and that they work as a team. And as a leader, it's really important to recognize that no one person, no matter how brilliant they are, no one person can make culture change by themselves. So looking at even from the top down approach in leadership, when you think about people, you have to build a team of trusted believers in what you believe. You have to have a team of you to initiate culture change. This isn't a journey that you take by yourself. So build your team. Find your people. Who are the ones that are as passionate about safety and quality culture as you and that will join you in that journey and that are empowered to take part in that journey with you. And if we think about the processes of the organization, how you manage, how you coordinate, the systems you have in place, the facilities and the equipment, how consistent everything is, how coordinated everything is, those inner mechanisms of the organization. You might think, oh, that's not a job for me. I work over here. That's about what happens on the shop floor. But, actually, again, the top down leadership role, you play a really crucial role in those processes of the company. You need to show support for them. You need to give them what they need to be as effective as they can, the right equipment, the right systems, the right coordination, the right management, but also you need to lead by example. If there are policies in place about protective clothing or about hygiene or anything to do with safety and quality, you need to lead. You need to show them first. The smallest of your policies and procedures must be followed by you more than anyone in the organization to continually show this is how we do things here. This is how we like things to be done. When people see somebody in leadership doing something, it has more of an impact than seeing other people do things because they see that it's coming from a decision making layer within the company. So what about proactivity? Being proactive, not reactive. How can you do that as a leader, and what does that involve? Well, in proactivity, we have different aspects to look at in terms of culture. We have external awareness, legislation, other companies, global standards, incidents, outbreaks that we see happening around the world. We have risk foresight, thinking ahead of what risks could be coming. Things like change and innovation, learning as an organization, knowing how and when to invest. These are all things that are proactive to the organization. And as a leader, you need to be aware of and responsive to what's new, what's coming, whether it's an outbreak that occurred in a product that's similar to yours, whether it's a new change in the legislation, whether it's some new technology that you could be investing in for the future, as well as focusing on the inner mechanisms of the company, it's really important to stay aware of what's new as well. And that's part of the leadership role. And then finally, if we look at purpose, the purpose of the organization, what's in here? In purpose, we talk about vision and values, strategy, targets, and metrics. And as a leader, it's really important that you show a passion for that vision and those values and that you set the targets and metrics in line with them, that they don't conflict with them. So if part of your vision is to have a really strong safety and quality culture, if part of your values is to have a really strong safety and quality culture, you need to show that in everything you do and talk about it. When you have a meeting, pull up the values and talk about them. Say what we're doing today, it connects with this value of the company. Remind people that they're not just sitting on a website or a poster, but that they're a living and breathing part of the organization. And be open and honest with people. Companies have to make profit, and they have to survive. Their business values too, but safety and quality can't be compromised along the way. So sometimes you might have to have challenging conversations, and it's better to be honest and open and say we have competing values sometimes. We have to work out a way to make sure targets are met, but safety and quality aren't compromised. Let's have a discussion. How are we gonna do that? It's much better to bring these things into the conversation than to not talk about them and just to continue and hope people do the right thing. So quite a lot there that leaders have to do, a lot that you have to be aware of in culture, and a lot that you have to encourage and take part in. So let's move on now at what we have to do from a bottom up perspective too. So back to people, bottom up. It's not just about the leadership team having this great gang of people that believe in safety and quality. You also really need to know what's going on in the workforce as well. The workforce all the way through the organization at every level are a vital part of your culture, and they help to shape and build it, not just the leaders. The leaders have more power, but the workforce can also shape and influence what becomes normal day to day. So finding a way to hear what they are saying and understand what they're experiencing is really important. How do you know what people are thinking? How do you know what they're doing? Having a culture survey is a really important part of this, and there's other things you might do. Employee feedback mechanisms, discussion groups, meetings, one on one conversations. As much as you can do to gather that input, empower people to speak up. The last thing we need is people not speaking up. We want them to feel that they can speak up about anything that they are thinking and experiencing. And, also, when we think about processes in a company, we talked about systems and management. And we might think, well, that's a leadership role to set that and create that, and the workforce just follows it. But, actually, usually, the only people who know if your systems work, really work, are the workforce using them. The only people that know if there are any workarounds, any corners that have to be taken, any rules that have to be bent to get things done on time, and if things that go wrong on a regular basis, any struggles, that's the frontline workforce who know. So somehow they have to be involved in the creation of policies, procedures, standards, whether that's a standard operating procedure or a work instruction. Somehow, you have to involve your workforce who know the reality in the review and improvement or even creation of systems in place in the company. So this is something that's really important to do. And if you're not doing it, something that's important to start doing, getting their voices and their input into the creation and review and improvement of all those different aspects of your process. And then if we think about productivity again, we talked about leaders being aware of what's going on outside the four walls of the company, what's new, what technology is coming around the corner. But, also, it's really important to share the learning and change journey with all of your employees, whether that is sharing the results of a culture survey, sharing your ideas for new technology or improvements, hearing about an outbreak in a similar company and sharing that with your teams. Let people be aware of what's going on in those decisions so that they feel more part of them, they feel more committed to them, and also get their ideas as well along the way. And then finally, the purpose. The purpose of the organization. It's really important to share where you're going and why you're going in that direction with all of your employees, again, so they can feel more part of the journey and have more confidence in what's happening. And, also, when we think of targets and metrics, it's really important to share what we call mutually beneficial goals. So when you set a target or you identify a key metric, it really can influence how people behave. So it's really important to pick the right one. If you choose a target that you want less risks in the company or you want less nonconformative, you might think that's a positive. But what might happen is people just stop hiding them. So it's always a matter of thinking about what's mutually beneficial when I set this target, when I set this goal. What's the outcome that I'm trying to get to, and how can I make sure we're in this together? So quite a lot there. And one of the big questions in culture is where do I start? What should I focus on first? And one of the requirements of the schemes, the main requirement of the food safety scheme certainly is to have a culture action plan. So that you need to show the auditor, this is my understanding of my culture. This is where I'm going. This is how I plan to get there, and this is the deadline and the measurement that I'm gonna make. So you need to have a focused action plan. You can't do everything at once. And each site, whether it's a factory, an office, a store, a restaurant, everyone should have their own action plan that's specific to them and their culture understanding. But if you're in a company with multiple factories or restaurants or stores or even multiple teams in the same factory, you can definitely share parts of your action plan and have some shared goals that work for all of you to enhance that coordination and efficiency, sharing resources, sharing ideas. And it's good to have that balance when you look at action planning. A typical view of an action plan template is here. So what we have here is, first of all, identify what parts of your company culture are the lowest in terms of where they rank. If you've done a survey, if you've identified there are this attitude and this behavior are the lowest, for example. So let's say it's a behavior. People not washing their hands at a key moment. Or let's say it's an attitude. People not taking people not being confident to speak up if there's an issue. So you identify what those lowest parts of your culture are. You consider that level of risk. Is that something important? If yes, it's a low scoring item, and there's a risk. You put it into your action plan. So you're really choosing based on relative score plus risk. If you have lots of different items and there's a few of them that are low and you don't know which one to put in first, we would always say filter. So go for the most specific to food safety, for example, if you have some general and some food safety items. And then from there, you fill in the action plan. So you identify your current status, for example, your score on the survey. You set a target. So where do you want to be? So let's say people's confidence to speak up was at 50%, and you want it to be at 70%. That would be a reasonable target if you think you're gonna do the activities necessary to get it there. Then you would plan the activities around that. Well, how do we get people to speak up more? We need a mechanism. We need them to feel confident. We need to show them that when they do speak up, we take it seriously. We need to make sure no one ever causes problems for people who speak up. So there's lots of steps that might then be necessary, just the mechanism for how they speak up, but the psychological support around that and the outcomes of that. What's the deadline for the activities we're gonna set? It might be setting up the new mechanism, sharing the communication of the first set of feedback. All these things need a deadline. And then how are we gonna monitor that? How are we gonna check that we've done a good job? Are we gonna get employee feedback? Are we gonna look at the volume of things that are raised? How are we gonna measure if that was successful or not? And then finally, when you do the culture survey again in the future, you'll see if that part of your survey if the score has gone up or not. So lots to do in terms of working on this. But, hopefully, when you get into the swing of it, you have the action plan template and you have survey data, you can really start to work on this in a more strategic way. So culture goes from being something quite big and nebulous to something more detailed and specific and plannable. And that's everything from me today. So we've looked at what leaders need to do, how to encourage all the things that the workforce need to do, what to focus on first, and what you do in relation to action planning. And I'm really happy to answer any questions as are the rest of the team here today that you might have on culture. We have about fifteen minutes, I think, to answer any questions that you have. Thank you, Joe. I think we've lost Prateek. Yes. Let me just pick up some of the questions from the chat. Alright. So the first one comes in, Joe, is how can middle management like QA and QC influence culture when facing resistance from their operations team? This is a great question, and it's a really perfectly timed question because I talked about top down and bottom up. And, of course, for people in the middle, you've got the challenges on both sides. So when you're in the middle layer of an organization, you don't have ultimate power to make every decision, but you're not in the workforce doing the actual frontline work, you're set there with a mixture of challenges from both sides, and you have to work with both. So it's very, very challenging. Your responsibility is almost doubled in a way because you have to communicate with the people that you work for that might be further away from what's happening and don't see everything that you see. So you have to have ways of communicating with them to share with them what's happening, what's important, what your ideas are for how to improve the company culture. But you also need to have a different way of communicating with your workforce and listening to your workforce. And I would say, if there's a conflict, if people aren't aligned, then the first thing we need to do is find out what's behind that conflict. Because we should be working towards the same goal, but sometimes in organizations, it can feel like we're not. It can feel like we're actually working towards slightly different goals. Somebody's focusing on budget. Somebody's focusing on getting the product out the door. Somebody's focusing on the quality and trying to stop that happening too quickly. Someone's focusing on just trying to get the job done as well as they can and move on. And where we have those slightly different priorities, it's really important, first of all, to understand them and understand where each different person is coming from and then have those open communications so that we can try to work out where that conflict is coming from. Ultimately, we've got the same broad goal, the success of the company and the brand, and the safety and quality of the product. We've all got the same big goal, but on a day to day basis, maybe there's conflict in terms of those more detailed and nuanced priorities and goals. And it's okay to talk about that. It's important to talk about that. To say, yes. We're all on the same page on a big sense, but let's get into the nitty gritty, we call it. Let's get into the detail. Where's this conflict coming from? It's okay that we're not all thinking in exactly the same way, but let's try to find a way to communicate and work together. These are really diff difficult and challenging steps, but the first step in all of it has to be understanding, and that comes through taking a survey, having more communications and discussions, and trying to get the bottom of the reason. There's usually a good reason. People, almost all of the time, want the right things. It's just that there's some conflict around how they want to get there and why they want to get there and the information that they've had. So, usually, open communication is a really effective first step in how to get there. Alright. The next one, I think I can take that one. It's the question here is, NSF certification is based on which global standard? Well, NSF started with writing standards about eighty two years back, and NSF provides certification against multiple internationally recognized global standards depending on the industry, the product type, the regulatory requirements. There's no single NSF standard. Instead, NSF certifies organizations based on the specific global or GFSI benchmark standard the company chooses to comply with. Now for GFSI benchmark standards, NSF offers certifications to globally accepted food safety and quality standards like VRCGS, FSSC 22,000, SQF, IFS. The other recognized worldwide, and these are recognized by the world these are recognized by retailers, regulators, and the global brands. For packaging and distribution, we do VRCGS. For packing materials, BRCGS for storage and distribution, ISO 22,000, ISO 9,001. For product certifications, we do the NSF ANSI standards for water systems, filtering, plumbing, sanitation equipment. We do NSF non GMO, organic, plant based, gluten free certification programs. For dietary supplements, we do NSF one seventy three. For food equipments to sanitation standards, we do NSF on, say, three fifty one, 64. For management systems, we for quality, we do 9,001. For environmental, we do 14,001. For information security, we do 27,001. So NSF certification is based on global standards that client wishes to be certified against, and that could be the GFSI, ANSI standard, or the ISO management systems or any specialist product certification schemes that we can cater to. So it's a flexible portfolio that we offer. Thank you for that, Nidhi. I I think some of the questions are very pertinent to the content that has been, you know, discussed here in the webinar. So moving on, I think we do have a, you know, a lot of questions to answer before we move out. I see there are some questions which have also come in the q and a chart. So I would request all the people to just keep punching any specific questions that they have in the q and a tab, and we'll try to answer those. The ones that we are not able to answer here, I will request, you know, a tabulation of those questions to be sent to Joanne so that she can answer them, and I can then share the PDF of those after the webinar gets over. We'll try to answer the maximum that we can today. So let's see. Okay. So we have next question coming in from Kiranjit Vijayan from Oman. He wants to understand how can middle management like QA and QC influence culture when facing resistance from operations team. So it's a three pronged question that he has asked. So how can middle management like QA, QC influence culture when facing resistance from the operations team? What are the most effective training methods to change the behavior, not just the not just improve knowledge at food handlers, and how do we motivate frontline staff to take ownership of the food safety instead of seeing it as a QC responsibility? I think very pertinent questions. So, Johan, would you want to take these? Absolutely. So I think with the the part about the conflict, we talked about that a little bit before in relation to understanding where the conflict is coming from. And these are interconnected because then in terms of training, it's really important that we can use really good training methods to give people the knowledge and information they need to reduce those aspects of conflict. And it goes all the way through then to empowering people to do the right thing because of the way that they've been trained and communicated with and the way they've understood what they need to do. I worked a long time in training and education. And for me, one of the single most important parts when I think about training is the difference between a master, an expert, and a novice. A novice doesn't understand the situation in a lot of detail, but they might know how to communicate it in a very simple level. The expert understands the situation in a lot of detail, and they communicate it in a very complicated way. The master understands the information in a detailed way, but they can communicate it in a simple way. So when we think about training, for me, the biggest thing in training, taking complexity and making it simple and making it understandable and making it matter to the person that you're talking to. Most people will do the right thing if they understand it's the right thing to do. If you have someone that isn't complying with something that looks simple and straightforward to you, it's not because they want to do the wrong thing. It's because they might not understand how that fits in to the bigger picture of the ultimate goal of safety and quality. So part of the trainer's job is to help them understand how every small thing that they're being asked to do fits into this bigger piece of safety and quality for the organization, safety for the consumer, safety for the child that will eat the product. So training, it's about taking something that's complicated, making it simple, making it relevant, emotionally connecting to what that information is doing and helping people to understand why. And the other biggest thing I picked up in my in my training years was that interaction is key. One way training isn't really training. It's communication. To train somebody, you have to be having some kind of interaction. You have to hear what they think, have a conversation, go backwards and forwards. That's how you can really get the information to the person at the level they need. That's what the master does. They take the information to the level that the person they're talking to needs, whatever level they're at. They can go high, middle, and low in the way they communicate that information, but you only know that if you're interacting with the person that you're training. So there's a few little bits there, I think, that hopefully are useful in terms of training. And I think that connects very much to that latter point about empowering people as well-to-do the right thing. Hopefully, that kind of answers all of it in one go. Absolutely. I think that was a brilliant summation of three questions, you know, woven into one. And I think, you know, the people, they would also try and relate to the real life situations that you just shared. So, yep, I I think we have a next question coming in from BG, Ravi Kumar Shashvi from Mal Malpay Fresh Marine Export Private Limited. He asked how to evaluate all grade effectiveness of food and product safety culture. So there's different ways of doing it. The way that we assess culture and culture excellence is through an anonymous and confidential survey. And the reason we do it that way is so that people can feel very comfortable giving their honest opinions. And we use an anonymous and confidential survey that covers all of the four p's that I explained earlier. We have questions on people, process, proactivity, and purpose. And we have questions about teams, about leadership, about the premises, about the work experience, about the department, the company, personal feelings. We have all of these different aspects because all of this is necessary to really understand your culture on a deep level. So for me, while I started my career in interviewing, I I used to be a very much a qualitative psychologist, and I would interview people. I have developed my methodology into an online quantitative method because that way we can reach millions of people quickly and easily, anonymously, and confidentially. And that way, we can get that kind of data. So as long as the questions are written in the right way, you can do this anonymous and confidential style of data gathering about your culture, and you can still get the insights that you need. Sure. I see that we are just starting the reverse countdown for the webinar to end. So I think we'll just hurry through the questions. And then as I said, the questions that remain unanswered, we can try and answer those in a subsequent feedback email. So quickly, we have a question from Samuel. He says that how do you solve the conflict between the operations and the quality department? Mostly when the executive chef is the one violating the safety rules most of the time, and it's still very close to the top management as their life support system. Again, I think this really comes back to understanding the motivations and the passions of each person. I've worked with a lot of chefs. My father was a chef for many years before he moved into education. And chefs are very sensible, practical people who want to do a good job. They're also very creative and innovative. And what I found working with chefs is that if they have rules that they don't believe in and they don't agree with, they won't do them because they need to get the job done. Yeah. But if they have rules they believe in, they will do them all of the time, and they will commit to them. And usually, they're doing things mostly right anyway, but there might be those few things that you want to tweak. One of the things that we found was actually sometimes it was modifying the system when we heard the views of the chefs and the workers. It wasn't just trying to modify the chefs and the workers to the system. It was a bit of both. So I think sometimes when there's conflict, what is it in the system that's not working? Assuming everybody wants to do a good job and everybody wants to make safe quality food, what is it in the system that's causing this conflict? Could that be changed first? Could there be a compromise? One of the examples I have is when I worked for the UK government, the government were trying to implement a program where people had to write down the temperature of everything they cooked, and they had to write down the temperature of the fridge constantly throughout the day. And the chefs all said no. And we said, yeah. That's fair. It's a no. They can't do that and do their job. And, also, they don't need to because they have other mechanisms. So we developed a system which was about only documenting things when they were wrong. So you have routine checks, and then you write things down when you've seen a problem because chefs are checking everything all the time anyway. That's part of their job. This was in a very small restaurant situation. You can't do this in a factory. But my point is sometimes you can compromise. You can take what people want and what the system wants, and you can find something in between. If you can get to that solution, then everybody will commit to it and implement it more readily. So, yeah, again, why is there the conflict? There's probably a good reason. And if you can figure it out together and compromise together, you then take shared ownership in that system. It's not just you having to tell somebody else what to do. Try and come up with something together, and then you have a shared sense of responsibility. It's a hard job in QA. You don't wanna have all the responsibility for yourselves and trying to make everyone do things. You wanna try and share that responsibility out, create shared standards, shared SOPs, get other people engaged and committed to next time about what you do. Because what you do is absolutely vital to the organization. And if you can get everybody on board with that, it makes it much easier. So hopefully, answers the question in a long way. around. Yeah. Thank you. I think that indeed was required, you know, because it, again, is a very sensitive topic when it comes to manpower within an organization. So, yeah, thank you for that, Joanne. That reminds me that we are running a quick survey that should have hit you all the screens right now. So while Joanne and the team are answering the questions, I would request you to also quickly answer the questions that would help us get better and, you know, create a better customer experience for from the next webinar onwards. So please do fill in that survey and help us understand how we can get a little better. So so next question comes from Estrella. She asked that, is there a common timeline on when an organization can see a change in culture based on your gathered data from your other organizations through the years and that this system was implemented? Yeah. It's a good question. The bigger you are as a company, the slower you're going to change. And the longer you've been established as a company, the slower you are to change. So if you're in a very big company that's been around for a very long time, it's like moving a supertanker in the water. If you're a little company and you're quite new, it's like being in a jet ski. So it's very different depending on how big and well established you are as an organization. So you have to set your expectations. You can change. You can change your culture, but you can't make massive changes quickly. So what we do with assessing culture, which is really important, is we break it down to individual parts of knowledge, attitude, and behavior, like people speaking up is, for example, perhaps someone having confidence to speak up the attitude or somebody speaking up the behavior or somebody knowing what the food safety risks are, the knowledge. We break it down into something small, and then we focus on changing that one small thing. Not changing culture as a whole, but changing that one knowledge, attitude, or behavior. And we focus on that, and we put our energy into that. And we will make a change, and we will make a positive impact in the organization. But it's about really managing expectations, making it bite size, focusing in on what you can change in your team, and doing your best to change that. And then, usually, we work with people who measure their culture once a year. And over a year, you can see change. You can't see change in. a month when you're talking about attitudes and behaviors, but you can see them when you're looking on an annual basis. But as I said, you would never look at your total culture score and look for change. It's too small, especially if you're big and well established. You'd look for the change in the behavior attitude or knowledge that you had decided you were gonna focus on, and it will ripple out and make positive change on other things as well. But you definitely can't take it all on at. once. Yeah. I I think that is something, you know, which most of us do realize, but at times we require a little bit of reinforcement on that. So, yes, thank you for that, Johan. I think we have time for a couple of questions before we end the session. So I have one question from Kavita, which says how food safety culture differs from compliance only approach. Would you want to answer that? Yeah. So I I think it depends what you're looking at when you say compliance culture. But if you mean how to get from compliance culture to safety culture so that it's more inherent, then that's a useful it's a useful goal. It's a nice goal to have. So if everyone's doing the right thing and you're wondering and it's a very interesting thing to wonder. Are they doing it because they have to do it, or are they doing it because they believe in it? Are they doing it because we've got a culture of compliance? Everybody must do the right thing all the time, but I don't know if everybody really believes it. Are they doing it because they really understand the the impact of that on safety, or are they doing it just because they know they have to tick that box? The best way is to ask people, is to have that one on one conversation. Tell me about what you're doing here. Oh, what what what why do we do it that way? What's that? And when people answer you, oh, we do it because that's how everybody does it, or we do it because actually if we don't do it that way, we get in trouble, or we do it this way because it helps safety, or we do it this way because it's good for quality. So you'll know in the conversations. And the outcome is the same. The positive outcome is the same. But when you move to a culture of people doing things because they believe in them, then they won't be compromised if something goes wrong. So that's the difference. If you're doing it because you think you have to, but then there's some kind of crisis or there's pressure or there's a hurry, you might let it slip. If you're doing it because you really believe in it, then you'll never compromise it. And that's what we want to get to in terms of people and people's understanding of safety and quality. Thank you. Thank you, Jo Anne. I think the last question coming up, I think it has to do with the periodicity. So how often do an organization needs to conduct a product safety and quality survey? Is it something, you know, that you would want to enlighten us on? So for most companies, they will do it annually, and they will tie it in with their annual audit, their annual senior management meeting about culture. They'll tie it in with annual decisions that they make so that they can use that data and other data streams to make strategic decisions as a company. The best way to use culture data is in collaboration with your audit data, your monitoring data. Look at them together. Look at the bigger picture of what it's telling you. But some companies will do things differently on a different timetable, but certainly the the norm, I would say, is for people to do it annually. When you do your culture data when you when you do your culture survey and you get your data, it's gonna be at least a year before you're gonna see any made any cultural shift usually depending on what it is that you've set. So annual is enough time that you'll see the impact of what you've done. But, certainly, it can also be done on different schedules if that's what a company needs. Sure. Thank you, Joan. I I know that it's been a long session. So the remainder of the questions, if there are any because I see a lot of questions which are worded very closely and, you know, the sense is the same. So we try to answer the maximum that we could during the session. The ones that get still that still remain, I'll just jot those down and write to Johan. And then perhaps once I get the answers for those, I'll write back to all the people who have requested those. So with that, I think we would come to an end of the webinar. I would sincerely want to thank you, Joanne, Virender, and Adi, for the excellent presentation and the engaging session, and a big thank you for all who, you know, took time to participate in this webinar. Thank you all for joining us. We hope you found this webinar informative and insightful. If you have any further questions or require additional information, please don't hesitate to contact us through our social channels, or please visit respective websites of NSF and BRCGS. Please help us improve the future webinars by sharing your thoughts and completing the survey that I have just shared. Have a great day, and stay safe. Thank you once again, Joanne, Nidi, and Virendar. Have a great day ahead. Bye bye. Thank you, Pradeep. Thank you. you, Thank. you. My. Everyone. pleasure. Bye bye.